Educators' and Preceptors' Perceptions of Student Competence Assessment in Athletic Training

Document Type

Poster

Abstract

Context: Athletic training educators and preceptors play a critical role in assessing student competence across didactic and clinical domains to ensure that athletic training students are prepared for autonomous practice. Objective: Explore how athletic training educators and preceptors assess student competence within either respective setting. Design: Cross-sectional, web-based qualitative survey. Setting: Accredited athletic training programs across the United States. Participants: A total of 543 participants (327 educators, 216 preceptors) affiliated with CAATE-accredited programs. Main Outcome Measures: Open-ended responses regarding student competence assessment were analyzed using a consensual qualitative research approach. Results: Skill/ability-based assessments were the most frequently reported across both educators (47.8%) and preceptors (40.4%), followed by clinical education evaluations and knowledge-based assessments. Educators commonly used practical exams and relied heavily on preceptor evaluations, while preceptors favored supervised clinical experiences and skill check-offs. Despite their importance, knowledge-based assessments were the least utilized. Conclusions: The findings suggest a shift in assessment emphasis from knowledge testing to applied clinical skill evaluation. However, reliance on preceptor evaluations—often conducted by individuals with limited formal training in education—raises concerns about consistency and accuracy. The AT Milestones are recommended as a standardized framework to enhance evaluation practices across both didactic and clinical settings. Further research is needed to determine the effectiveness of this tool in bridging educational gaps.

Publication Date

Spring 2025

Comments

Poster presented at ATSU-ASHS DAT Spring - 2025. This is a Kubify based presentation hosted at https://api.ltb.io/show/ACIEW It includes a video presentation, references, a PowerPoint presentation, and summary poster.

This document is currently not available here.

Share

COinS